[WSMDiscuss] Brutalising Labourers, Jailing Dissidents
subhash.gatade at gmail.com
Sun Apr 19 07:09:46 CEST 2020
Brutalising Labourers, Jailing Dissidents
A medical emergency is no pretext to impose a political emergency.
Subhash Gatade <https://www.newsclick.in/author/Subhash%20Gatade>
*(* https://www.newsclick.in/Brutalising-Labourers-Jailing-dissidents )
19 Apr 2020
How many policemen in civil clothes are required to deliver a mere summons
to an editor of a web journal 700-k away in an age of email and WhatsApp?
The recent action of the Uttar Pradesh police, where it sent a posse of 7-8
policemen, in civil clothes, in a black SUV with no number plates, to
Siddharth Varadarajan’s residence in Delhi to deliver a summons has
prompted this question.
Definitely the police did not bother to ponder over how Varadarajan, editor
of The Wire, will present himself to the authorities during a lockdown
which has brought trains, flights and even private transport to a
The manner in which the issue has unfolded has caused an international
uproar with 3,500 jurists, scholars, actors, artists and writers condemning
Uttar Pradesh Police’s actions against The Wire, and saying that a “medical
emergency should not serve as the pretext for the imposition of a de facto
How Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath’s government will respond remains to be
seen, but the story in The Wire on the Tablighi Jamaat, which also noted
that “Indian believers” responded late to the viral epidemic obviously
provoked the powers-that-be into action. The episode has brought into sharp
focus the priorities of the government during the epidemic, which it is
supposedly fighting a “war” against.
During this lockdown, most political activities stand suspended, and the
citizenry are restricted to their homes, but a BJP-ruled government is
still chasing one member of the independent press. The Delhi police has
brought ignominy on itself by failing to apprehend members of a 200-strong
gang which unleashed violence in JNU in January 2020 despite catching their
movements on CCTV. Its handling of the north-east Delhi violence, where it
is alleged that they did not respond to distress calls from those under
attack, is equally lacklustre. Suddenly, the same police has become
proactive and arrested two students of Jamia Millia Islamia, Saroofa
Zargar, an MPhil student and media manager of the Jamia Coordination
committee and Meeran Haider, a PhD student, who is president of the RJD or
Rashtriya Janata Dal’s youth wing’s Delhi unit.
A joint statement by teacher’s organisations has called this a “retaliatory
revengeful action against those who were active in the movement... on
trumped-up charges relating to the North East Delhi riots and other
These students were at the forefront of the historic movement to defend
constitutional rights, and opposed the CAA and the NRC. Their movement had
a massive impact throughout the country. Despite provocations from the
police and right-wing elements, the movement stuck with its non-violent
path and in the wake of the global Novel Coronavirus pandemic, they
Demanding immediate release of these leaders this joint statement signed by
FEDKUTA, DUTA, JNUTA and Jamia Teachers Association JTA as well as AIPWA,
IPTA, Janwadi Lekhak Sangh, Jan Sanskriti Manch etc underlined that Safoora
Zargar is pregnant and requires proper care and medical supervision.
The timing of the arrest of student leaders/activists and targeting of
others is significant.
Remember, this happened exactly when the functioning of the home
ministry—which is directly under Shah’s supervision—was increasingly coming
under a scanner, including for how the Delhi police has been acting during
the last few months.
Or, consider the Markaz event where the Tablighi Jamaat held its programme
in Delhi. No doubt, theirs was an unwise decision, but can it be singled
out for this and the entire Muslim community targeted for their mistake?
What about role of Delhi Police and the Ministry of External Affairs?
Should not they be blamed equally? Remember, the TJ could not have held its
programme without permission from Delhi Police, which, again, is directly
under the Home Ministry.
The Maharashtra government did not allow the TJ to hold its convention in
March because of the Covid-19 epidemic. Anil Deshmukh, home minister of
Maharashtra pointedly asked why the Union Home Ministry did not act in
time. Not a very comforting question for someone who is compared with
Sardar Patel by his followers.
The government was also facing flak for being ill-prepared to provide
essential supplies during the lockdown which it had suddenly put in place.
Besides, Shah has remained tight-lipped about the migrant labourers who
fled on foot, by bus or train, for their homes right after it was imposed.
Yet, it turns out that the home ministry had no qualms in making special
arrangements for the return—in around 30 super-luxury buses—of around 2,000
Gujaratis who were stranded across Uttarakhand in the aftermath of the
lockdown. The operation was wrapped in so much secrecy that Uttarakhand’s
transport minister was not even aware of it.
Filing criminal charges against a reputed editor, apprehending activists
who were running peaceful democratic movements under serious charges and
arresting Gautam Navlakha and Anand Teltumbde, two of India’s finest human
rights activists, make it crystal clear that Covid-19 has provided an
opportunity to target dissenters and suppress civil liberties.
Barring cheerleaders, all are being penalised if they hold ideas contrary
to the regime. A commitment to speak truth to power and ideals enshrined in
the Constitution is proving costly for many. A statement issued by NAPM on
the occasion of Ambedkar Jayanti, 14 April, details how governments are
using the Covid-19 lockdown for “destroying the democratic institutions and
processes, restrict fundamental rights and freedom and criminalise any
critique as sedition and anti-national. The federal character of the Indian
state is being put under the strain and being eroded constantly.”
It talks about filing of FIRs against Prashant Bhushan, Ashlin Mathew,
Kannan Gopinathan and the continued incarceration of peasant leader Akhil
Gogoi in Assam, of Dr Kafeel Khan in Uttar Pradesh, of Abhilakh Singh,
secretary of Theka Mazdoor Kalyan Samiti in Pantnagar University, teacher
Konsam Victor Singh and Dr Laifungbam Debabrata Roy in Manipur, Soneswar
Narah and Pranab Doley of Jeepal Krishak Shramik Sangha in Assam and many
others arbitrarily arrested for their Facebook posts, WhatsApp forwards
and, most importantly, for raising questions over the government actions.
In addition, the government circulated a Cabinet note which has talked of
raising the official working hours from 8 to 12 hours a day, defeating the
hard-won rights of workers in a single stroke.
Teltumbde’s prophesy on the eve of his arrest is worth pondering over
again: “In the name of the ‘nation’, such draconian laws that denude
innocent people of their liberties and all constitutional rights are
“A jingoist nation and nationalism have been weaponised by the political
class to destroy dissent and polarise people. The mass frenzy has
accomplished complete de-rationalisation and inversion of meanings... it is
with a feeble hope that I write to you at such a grim moment.
“Well, I am off to NIA custody and do not know when I shall be able to talk
to you again.
“However, I earnestly hope that you will speak out before your turn comes.”
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the WSM-Discuss