[WSMDiscuss] [REDlistserve] Solidarity Means Dismantling The System Everywhere (Progressive International)

[Ashish Kothari]

thanks, Jai, for posting this, and for your questions prefacing the post.

while every call for bringing together 'progressive' forces around the 
world together is prima facie to be welcomed, it also bears scrutiny 
w.r.t. the track record of the people who are issuing the call?

having read the statement below, as also looked at the website of the 
Progressive International, I do not find clarity on a number of issues, 
including the nature of democracy (or governance) they espouse, or the 
nature of economy. 'Dismantling the system' is a nice slogan, but what 
system? I ask this especially because while some of the signatories are 
well-known for their commitment to deep, radical democracy and an 
ecologically and socially embedded economy, others have a track record 
that does not inspire confidence. At least two have been heads or deputy 
heads of state, and while in so-called 'revolutionary' parties leading 
their countries they were explicitly against American imperialism and 
hegemony (most welcome), their internal politics and handling of hte 
economy was not particularly oriented to 'dismantling the system'. Did 
they move at all towards defunding or dismantle the police, "department 
by department'? did they significantly reduce the centralised power of 
the nation-state and enable much greater decision-making by local 
communities? did they move substantially away from extractivist 
economies, placing much more trust in the economic wisdom and practices 
of communities (while helping them as necessary)? A few years back I was 
in a community in Ecuador, and the local mayor and other residents were 
telling us how Correa's approach to them was not necessarily any 
different from previous (right-wing) govts ... in fact that some 
progressive moves like embedding educational institutions in local 
languages and cultures and making them much less impositional from 
above, were reversed, as were moves towards agroecology (attached an 
article on this what we wrote after the visit). And enormously committed 
groups like Accion Ecologica were sought to be shut down because they 
protested against Correa's extractivist approach, supporting indigenous 
peoples who were impacted. In Bolivia, an indigenous president was not 
necessarily v. favourable to the agency and needs of many of the 
country's Amazonian indigenous peoples, as we heard from many of the 
area's peoples. Extractivism of various kinds continues apace. The 
'rights of nature' or 'mother earth' approaches that were enshrined in 
their constitution or in law were repeatedly ignored ... Alberto here, 
instrumental in moving the Ecuadorian constitution to recognise such 
rights and subsequently in Correa's govt briefly, resigned in protest, 
and can add more.

now out of power, its easy to talk of 'dismantling the system', but 
would they do it if they took over the govt again in any of these 
countries? or would they say 'in the current international capitalist 
system', we can't do it, so we have to retain centralised power, for the 
greater good of our people ... perhaps there is some merit in this 
argument, but it is not at all clear what stopped these people, when in 
power for a long enough period, from moving towards much greater 
economic democracy with ecological sensitivity, or deeper empowerment at 
the level of communities so that they could be more self-reliant, and be 
able to strongly resist hegemonic forces from above (right wing or 
orthodox left wing).

Just to be clear, I'd much prefer a leftwing govt than a rightwing one 
(esp. for welfare schemes, to safeguard basic rights against fascist 
forces, to sustain 'public sector' in crucial aspects of economy/social 
services etc) ... but on some matters I am not convinced that there is 
so much of a difference, if the leftwing is of the orthodox, 'hard party 
line' variety. Perhaps the hope is that the more radical elements in PI, 
including some named below, can enable some re-orientation towards such 
radical progressive approaches that truly dismantle the system ... 
including recognising that progressive forces are not only in the 'left' 
but in many other kinds of movements, as I'd tried to mention in my 
recent article 'Lives Matter' that i'd posted last week.

(my post wont go on some of the lists yours has gone on, but I'm adding 
a couple of other lists that have people who may find this discussion of 
interest).

thanks,

ashish


LATEST! Pluriverse: A Post-Development Dictionary (thepluriverse.org)
and www.globaltapestryofalternatives.org

Ashish Kothari
Kalpavriksh
Apt 5 Shree Datta Krupa
908 Deccan Gymkhana
Pune 411004, India
Tel: 91-20-25654239; 91-20-25675450
http://kalpavriksh.org
www.vikalpsangam.org
www.radicalecologicaldemocracy.org
www.iccaconsortium.org
www.acknowlej.org
http://ashishkothari51.blogspot.in/
Twitter: @chikikothari

On 23/06/20 12:24 am, Jai Sen wrote:
>
> Monday, June 22, 2020
>
> *Viruses in movement…, Solidarity in movement…, Resistance in movement…*
>
> [Aside from the content of this statement, as far as I know – though I 
> might have missed things - this is the first public Statement that the 
> recently-founded ‘Progressive International’ has made, on anything…. 
>  So this is worth noting by itself.
>
> [It ‘starts’ by making a not extraordinary but still useful statement :
>
> Protest movements around the world are rising up and reaching out. In 
> the streets of Santiago, young Chileans demonstrated against 
> widespread conditions of poverty, precarity, and police brutality. 
> Across India, millions of activists stood up to the racism and 
> anti-Muslim violence of the Modi government. And in Lebanon, 
> protestors have defied lockdown to demand their basic rights to food, 
> water, healthcare, and education.
>
> /It is in these planetary conditions that protests have erupted across 
> the United States./ And yet, there is something exceptional about 
> these protests — if only that they expose a deep fissure in the 
> doctrine of ‘American exceptionalism.’… [emphasis given]
>
> [It then goes on to say :
>
> Our challenge, now as always, is to organize: to turn these 
> spontaneous expressions of solidarity into an enduring international 
> movement to dismantle the institutions of racist state violence and 
> investigate the human rights abuses by US police departments, its 
> prison system, and its military, in particular.
>
> /That is why we founded the Progressive International: to make 
> solidarity more than a slogan/. Marches in cities like Auckland and 
> Amsterdam have sent an important signal to the US government that the 
> world is watching. But bearing witness is not enough. /Our task is to 
> translate the sentiment of solidarity into concrete actions that 
> advance a shared vision of racial and economic justice/. [emphases given]
>
> [It’s not clear though, who it is signalling by the ‘our’ here (as in 
> ‘Our task’) – that of all of ‘us’, or that of the Progressive 
> International… If the latter, then it would seem to be seeking to take 
> the mantle of ‘leadership’.  This will sort of define its politics.  
> Let’s see what they next do.  It will be interesting to see.
>
> [It’s also not just ‘interesting’ but a little extraordinary though 
> (and vaguely quaint), to see a self-styled movement organisation then 
> wear all (or most) of its badges in public, with detailed blurbs on 
> all the notables who are on its Council who have signed on to this 
> statement. Most movements go the other way, and are almost opaque 
> about such matters; here, it’s not just a list (of people who are, by 
> and large, quite well known) but with their details…  Interesting 
> politics !  (And worth ‘reading’ and thinking about.) :
>
> *Solidarity Means Dismantling The System Everywhere***
>
> Progressive International 
> <https://progressive.international/wire/2020-06-04-solidarity-means-dismantling-the-system-everywhere/en>
>
> https://popularresistance.org/solidarity-means-dismantling-the-system-everywhere/
>
>
>     PI Council members on the uprising in the United States and around
>     the world.
>
> A new solidarity movement is rising. From Los Angeles to Sao Paulo, 
> Minneapolis to London, “Black Lives Matter” is a cry and a demand 
> heard around the world.
>
> The message of this movement is powerfully simple: stop killing black 
> people — in their homes, on the streets, and traveling across the sea 
> to safer shores. Yet in its simplicity, it contains the seed of a 
> radical transformation in our planetary system, raging against a 
> machine of racist dispossession to make room for collective and 
> communal liberation everywhere.
>
> The last decade has witnessed a sharp turn in two terrifying 
> directions: turning in and cracking down. A new cohort of 
> authoritarians has shunned international cooperation in a retreat to 
> the nation-state and its ancient myths of blood and soil. A new set of 
> surveillance technologies has turned us in further, tightening and 
> militarizing state control over our communities. And the onset of the 
> Covid-19 pandemic has forced us further into locked-down isolation, 
> introducing — in some cases — the threat of a permanent state of 
> exception and the martial law attached to it.
>
> Protest movements around the world are rising up and reaching out. In 
> the streets of Santiago, young Chileans demonstrated against 
> widespread conditions of poverty, precarity, and police brutality. 
> Across India, millions of activists stood up to the racism and 
> anti-Muslim violence of the Modi government. And in Lebanon, 
> protestors have defied lockdown to demand their basic rights to food, 
> water, healthcare, and education.
>
> It is in these planetary conditions that protests have erupted across 
> the United States. And yet, there is something exceptional about these 
> protests — if only that they expose a deep fissure in the doctrine of 
> ‘American exceptionalism.’ We cannot ignore the particular hypocrisy 
> of the hegemon, which brags to the world of its ‘missions 
> accomplished’ and freedoms granted while oppressing its black, brown, 
> and native populations at home. And we should not overlook the opening 
> these protests have created to break with this hegemonic power and 
> advance toward a decolonized and multipolar world.
>
> An opening is an opening — not an assurance. The scenes that have 
> emerged from these international protests are those of a system at 
> breaking point. But there is no guarantee in which direction it will 
> break. It would be our grave error to underestimate the forces of 
> reaction and their capacity to leverage the present opportunity to 
> advance their repressive vision of ‘LAW & ORDER!’, as President Trump 
> so succinctly tweeted.
>
> Our challenge, now as always, is to organize: to turn these 
> spontaneous expressions of solidarity into an enduring international 
> movement to dismantle the institutions of racist state violence and 
> investigate the human rights abuses by US police departments, its 
> prison system, and its military, in particular.
>
> That is why we founded the Progressive International: to make 
> solidarity more than a slogan. Marches in cities like Auckland and 
> Amsterdam have sent an important signal to the US government that the 
> world is watching. But bearing witness is not enough. Our task is to 
> translate the sentiment of solidarity into concrete actions that 
> advance a shared vision of racial and economic justice.
>
> That means learning from each other’s struggles against state 
> violence, as in the case of the Lebanese activists who compiled a 
> toolkit for protestors across the US. That means providing resources, 
> where possible, to support the victims of police violence and their 
> families. And it means identifying our own respective roles in this 
> planetary system —wherever we may live — and delivering justice in our 
> own communities.
>
> Not all solidarities are the same. Far too often, expressions of 
> outrage at what is happening ‘over there’ act as cover to ignore, 
> dismiss, or otherwise minimize the ritual violence that happens right 
> here. Europeans marching to defund the Minneapolis police might demand 
> that their own governments defund Frontex, the EU border authority 
> responsible for illegal detentions and deportations across the 
> Mediterranean.
>
> The same holds true in the opposite direction. The expansion of the US 
> empire through the unlimited funding of its military-industrial 
> complex has boomeranged back home, arming local police forces with the 
> same equipment that the US has deployed in its endless wars overseas. 
> If the protests in the United States are to give rise to a new sense 
> of solidarity among its citizens, then it must extend to all 
> populations that have suffered US imperial aggression and sustained 
> occupation — especially those native populations on whose 
> dispossession the nation itself was founded.
>
> The infrastructure of racist policing is already international. US law 
> enforcement agencies are trained by the Israeli military. US arms 
> producers supply police forces across Brazil. US corporations equip 
> the Indian government with surveillance technology. And US methods of 
> stop-and-frisk in minority neighbourhoods have been exported around 
> the world.
>
> The task of our Progressive International is take stock of this 
> international infrastructure — to listen to activists and organizers 
> who have dedicated their lives to this fight — and to work with them 
> to dismantle it: brick by brick, dollar by dollar, police department 
> by police department.
>
>
> *List of signatories:*
>
> /Noam Chomsky is considered the founder of modern linguistics. He has 
> received numerous awards, including the Kyoto Prize in Basic Sciences, 
> the Helmholtz Medal and the Ben Franklin Medal in Computer and 
> Cognitive Science. Chomsky joined the UA in fall 2017, coming from the 
> Massachusetts Institute of Technology, where he worked since 1955 and 
> was Institute Professor, later Institute Professor emeritus./
>
> /Hilda Heine is Senator for Aur Atoll, Republic of the Marshall 
> Islands. She served as President of the RMI from 2016 to 2020, and the 
> Minister of Education before that. As RMI President, Heine took the 
> issue of climate change, an existential threat for the peoples of the 
> Marshall Islands and others in similar situations, to the 
> international stage to share the story and to increase others’ 
> awareness of RMI and the difficulties it faces due to climate change./
>
> /Ece Temelkuran is one of Turkey’s best- known novelists and political 
> commentators, appearing in the Guardian, New York Times, New 
> Statesman, and Der Spiegel. Her recent novel Women Who Blow on Knots 
> won the 2017 Edinburgh International Book Festival First Book Award. 
> She is the recipient of the PEN Translate Award, the New Ambassador of 
> Europe Prize, and “Honorary Citizenship” from the city of Palermo for 
> her work on behalf of oppressed voices./
>
> /Gael García Bernal is an actor. He began performing in stage 
> productions with his parents in Mexico, and later studied at the 
> Central School for Speech and Drama in London. He is a founder and the 
> president of Ambulante, an itinerant not-for-profit documentary film 
> festival promoting documentaries within Mexico and abroad. He has 
> recently opened his new production company, La Corriente del Golfo, 
> together with Diego Luna./
>
> /Áurea Carolina is a federal deputy for Minas Gerais state (BR), 
> affiliated with the Socialism and Liberty Party (PSOL). Áurea is part 
> of the Muitas municipalist movement, of #partidA (an informal party 
> composed dedicated to electing women into office), and of the Ocupa 
> Política network (devoted to boosting the occupation of the 
> institutional politics by progressive activists). Together with 
> Andréia de Jesus, Bella Gonçalves, and Cida Falabella, she takes part 
> in the “Gabinetona”, a forum where four parliamentary mandates work 
> collectively./
>
> /Celso Amorim is the longest serving foreign minister of Brazil to 
> date (1993-1994 and 2003-2010). He also served as Minister of Defense 
> (2011-2014). Amorim remains active in academic life and as a public 
> figure, having written a number of books and articles on matters 
> ranging from foreign policy to culture./
>
> /Renata Ávila is an international human rights lawyer. She is a 2020 
> Stanford Race and Technology Fellow at the Center for Comparative 
> Studies in Race and Ethnicity. She is a Board member for Creative 
> Commons, the Common Action Forum, Cities for Digital Rights, Article 
> 19 Mexico & Central America, and a Global Trustee of Digital Future 
> Society. She also serves as a member of the Coordinating Collective of 
> DiEM25./
>
> /Srećko Horvat is a philosopher. He has been active in various 
> movements for the past two decades. He co-founded the Subversive 
> Festival in Zagreb and, together with Yanis Varoufakis, founded 
> DiEM25. He published more than a dozen books translated into 15 
> languages, most recentlyPoetry from the Future,Subversion!,The 
> Radicality of LoveandWhat Does Europe Want?./
>
> /Scott Ludlam is a writer, activist and former Australian Greens 
> Senator. He served in Parliament from 2008 – 2017, and as Co-Deputy 
> Leader of his party from 2015 – 2017. Currently working as a freelance 
> researcher and troublemaker, while writing occasional pieces for 
> Meanjin, the Monthly, Junkee and the Guardian./
>
> /Carola Rackete studied nautical science in Elsfleth and conservation 
> management in Ormskirk, England. She has mainly been working on polar 
> research vessels and spent eight seasons in the Antarctic. Since 2016, 
> she has been volunteering on NGO ships and aircraft in the central 
> Mediterranean and, as captain of the SEA-WATCH 3, was arrested in 2019 
> for entering an Italian port to safeguard a group of rescued refugees./
>
> /Yanis Varoufakis is a member of the Hellenic Parliament and the 
> Secretary-General of MeRA25. He is the co-founder of DiEM25, and the 
> former finance minister of Greece. He is the author of several books, 
> including Adults in the Room and And The Weak Suffer What They Must?./
>
> /John McDonnell is a Member of Parliament for Hayes and Harlington. 
> From 2015 to 2020, he served as Shadow Chancellor of the Exchequer 
> under party leader Jeremy Corbyn./
>
> /Andres Arauz is a former Minister of Knowledge of Ecuador and a 
> former Central Bank General Director. He is a founding member of the 
> Dollarization Observatory and a former board member of the nascent 
> Bank of the South. He is currently based in Mexico City as a Doctoral 
> Fellow at the National Autonomous University of Mexico, UNAM./
>
> /Alicia Castro is political and union activist. She was the General 
> Secretary of the Union of Aeronavegantes, the founder of the Argentine 
> Workers Movement (MTA), and a member of the ITF Council. She served as 
> the Argentine ambassador to the United Kingdom from 2012 to 2016. 
> Before that, she served in ambassadorial posts in Venezuela and as the 
> National Deputy for the Province of Buenos Aires./
>
> /David Adler is the General Coordinator of the Progressive International./
>
> /Aruna Roy is a Founder-Member, Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sanghathan 
> (MKSS), National Campaign to People’s Right to Information (NCPRI), 
> and the School for Democracy (SFD). She was with the IAS from 
> 1968-1975. In 1975 she came to Ajmer District, Rajasthan to work with 
> the SWRC and the rural poor. In 1987 she moved to live with the poor 
> in a village called Devdungri, Rajsamand District in Rajasthan. In 
> 1990 she was part of the group that set up the MKSS. She has worked 
> for accessing constitutional rights for the poor – Right to 
> Information, Employment, Food Security etc. She was a member of the 
> National Advisory Council (NAC) from 2004-06 and 2010-13. She is 
> President of the National Federation of Indian Women (NFIW)./
>
> /Nikhil Dey is a leading Indian social activist and a co-founder of 
> the Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan (MKSS). MKSS is a People’s 
> Organisation and part of the growing Non-party political process in 
> India. The MKSS works with workers and peasants in the villages of 
> Central Rajasthan to strengthen participatory democratic processes, so 
> that ordinary citizens could live their lives with dignity and justice./
>
> /Ertuğrul Kürkçü is the current Honorary President of the Peoples’ 
> Democratic Party (HDP) and Honorary Associate of the Parliamentary 
> Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE). He was the co-chair of the 
> HDP in 2013-14 and the member of parliament for three successive terms 
> between 2011-2018. He spent 14 years as a prisoner between 1972-1986 
> for his political activism in Turkey, after which he helped found the 
> Freedom and Solidarity Party (ÖDP). After its disintegration, he 
> joined the united block of ‘Labor, Democracy and Freedom’ in 2011 what 
> successfully transformed into the HDP./
>
> /Nick Estes is a citizen of the Lower Brule Sioux Tribe. He is an 
> Assistant Professor in the American Studies Department at the 
> University of New Mexico. In 2014, he co- founded The Red Nation, an 
> Indigenous resistance organization. For 2017-2018, Estes was the 
> American Democracy Fellow at the Charles Warren Center for Studies in 
> American History at Harvard University. Estes is a member of the Oak 
> Lake Writers Society, a network of Indigenous writers committed to 
> defend and advance Oceti Sakowin (Dakota, Nakota, and Lakota) 
> sovereignty, cultures, and histories./
>
> /Paola Vega is a Costa Rican congresswoman. She is the chair of the 
> Environmental Committee and a member of the Economic and Women’s 
> Committees. Her main goals in environmental matters are to change 
> plastic consumption, pass a new and modern water law, ban gas and oil 
> exploration and exploitation, evolve to sustainable fishing practices, 
> and to promote green businesses and circular economies./
>
> /Elizabeth Gómez Alcorta is the Minister of Women, Genders and 
> Diversity of Argentina. Previously, she practiced law from more than 
> twenty years, representing victims of state terrorism and political 
> prisoners. She is also Professor at the University of Buenos Aires, 
> where she teaches criminal law. She has published numerous articles on 
> criminal law, human rights law and gender. She holds a law degree from 
> the University of Buenos Aires and has completed postgraduate studies 
> in law, sociology and political sciences./
>
> /Alvaro Garcia-Linera is a Bolivian politician from Cochabamba. He led 
> the indigenist Tupac Katari Guerrilla Army rebel group during the 
> early 1990s, and he was imprisoned from 1992 to 1997. In 2005, he was 
> elected Vice President of Bolivia, serving until his resignation in 
> November 2019./
>
> /Rafael Correa is former Constitutional President of the Republic of 
> Ecuador, 2007- 2017, and Chairman of the Eloy Alfaro Political and 
> Economic Thought Institute (IPPE). Rafael holds a Ph.D. and MSc. in 
> Economics from University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign and a MA in 
> Economics from the Catholic University of Louvain- la-Neuve, Belgium. 
> He obtained his first economics degree from the Catholic University of 
> Santiago de Guayaquil, Guayaquil, Ecuador./
>
>
> ____________________________
>
> Jai Sen
>
> Independent researcher, editor; Senior Fellow at the School of 
> International Development and Globalisation Studies at the University 
> of Ottawa
>
> jai.sen at cacim.net <mailto:jai.sen at cacim.net>
>
> Now based in New Delhi, India (+91-98189 11325) and in Ottawa, 
> Canada,on unceded and unsurrendered Anishinaabe territory(+1-613-282 2900)
>
> CURRENT / RECENT publications:
>
> Jai Sen, ed, 2018a –*/The Movements of Movements, Part 2 : Rethinking 
> Our Dance/*. Ebook and hard copy available atPM Press 
> <http://www.pmpress.org/>
>
> Jai Sen, ed, 2018b –*/The Movements of Movements, Part 1 : What Makes 
> Us Move ?/*(Indian edition). New Delhi : AuthorsUpfront, in 
> collaboration with OpenWord andPM Press.Hard copy available 
> atMOM1AmazonIN 
> <https://www.amazon.in/dp/9387280101/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1522884070&sr=8-2&keywords=movements+of+movements+jai+sen>,MOM1Flipkart 
> <https://www.flipkart.com/the-movements-of-movements/p/itmf3zg7h79ecpgj?pid=9789387280106&lid=LSTBOK9789387280106NBA1CH&marketplace=FLIPKART&srno=s_1_1&otracker=search&fm=SEARCH&iid=ff35b702-e6a8-4423-b014-16c84f6f0092.9789387280106.SEARCH&ppt=Search%20Page>, 
> andMOM1AUpFront <http://www.authorsupfront.com/movements.htm>
>
> Jai Sen, ed, 2017 –*/The Movements of Movements, Part 1 : What Makes 
> Us Move ?/*.New Delhi : OpenWord and Oakland, CA :PM Press.Ebook and 
> hard copy available atPM Press <http://www.pmpress.org/>//
>
> /SUBSCRIBE TO World Social Movement Discuss/,an open, unmoderated, and 
> self-organising forum on social and political movement at any level 
> (local, national, regional, and global).*To subscribe, simply send an 
> empty email towsm-discuss-subscribe at lists.openspaceforum.net 
> <mailto:wsm-discuss-subscribe at lists.openspaceforum.net>***
>
>
> -- 
> To reply to the author of this message, select "reply"; to reply to 
> the whole list, select "reply to all".
> ---
> You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google 
> Groups "Radical Ecological Democracy" group.
> To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send 
> an email to radical_ecological_democracy+unsubscribe at googlegroups.com 
> <mailto:radical_ecological_democracy+unsubscribe at googlegroups.com>.
> To view this discussion on the web, visit 
> https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/radical_ecological_democracy/446DF043-4766-4AA0-B52A-B4BD9503C6FD%40cacim.net 
> <https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/radical_ecological_democracy/446DF043-4766-4AA0-B52A-B4BD9503C6FD%40cacim.net?utm_medium=email&utm_source=footer>.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.openspaceforum.net/pipermail/wsm-discuss/attachments/20200623/5217b184/attachment.htm>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: Nabon article, as published REDWeb, 16.12.2017.pdf
Type: application/pdf
Size: 934820 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <https://lists.openspaceforum.net/pipermail/wsm-discuss/attachments/20200623/5217b184/attachment.pdf>